Skip to content

Is IQ Genetic? What Heritability Actually Means

Heritability is the most misunderstood number in this field, and the misunderstanding runs in a specific direction. People hear a high figure and conclude that intelligence is fixed, inherited and beyond influence. The actual finding supports none of those conclusions.

What follows is what the number means, what the research has established, and why the two best-evidenced findings in this area point in apparently opposite directions and are both correct.

What heritability is a measurement of

Heritability is not the proportion of your intelligence that came from your genes. That sentence does not describe anything measurable, and it is the source of nearly every error people make here.

Heritability is the proportion of the variation between people in a particular population at a particular time that can be attributed to genetic variation. It is a statement about a group, not about a person. Asking how heritable your own intelligence is makes about as much sense as asking what your personal unemployment rate is.

The five things heritability is routinely taken to mean, and does not
What people hear What heritability actually means
Half of my intelligence comes from my genes It is not a statement about an individual at all. It is about variation in a group
If it is heritable it cannot change Height is highly heritable and rose dramatically in a century through nutrition
Environment does not matter much Heritability is measured within one environment. Change the environment and the figure changes
It explains differences between groups Heritability within a group says nothing about what causes differences between groups
My child’s score is therefore fixed Schooling reliably raises measured intelligence and the gain persists

The height comparison in that table is the one that settles it for most people. Height is highly heritable, around 0.8 in developed countries. Average height in many countries rose by several inches over the twentieth century, through nutrition. High heritability and large environmental change sat together without contradiction, because heritability describes variation within a population, not the limits of what a population can do.

The findings that are solid

Plomin and Deary reviewed the evidence and set out several findings they considered firmly established (Plomin and Deary, 2015). Two are worth your attention.

The first is that heritability of intelligence increases with age. In young children it is around 0.2. By adulthood it is around 0.6 or higher. This is called the Wilson effect and it is the opposite of what almost everyone predicts.

0.000.200.400.600.80Age 5Age 7Age 10Age 12Age 16Age 20Age 30Heritability of intelligenceShared family environmentHeritability rises with age while shared family environment fadesProportion of variance
The Wilson effect, one of the five findings reviewed by Plomin and Deary (2015). Shape of the published pattern, not exact figures.

The mirror image is that shared family environment, everything siblings have in common by growing up in the same house, has a measurable effect in childhood and shrinks to near nothing by adulthood.

The likely explanation is not that genes switch on. It is that as people gain autonomy they increasingly select their own environments, and those choices correlate with their dispositions. A child is placed in an environment. An adult builds one. The genetic influence is partly operating through choices rather than around them.

The second finding is that no single gene matters much. Intelligence is influenced by very many genetic variants, each with a tiny effect. There is no gene for intelligence and there is not going to be a useful genetic test for it.

The finding that cuts the other way

Now put that beside the Norwegian conscript data.

Norway tested conscripts for decades, producing a dataset that includes brothers. Bratsberg and Rogeberg compared scores within families, between brothers born a few years apart. Scores rose by about 0.26 points a year for cohorts born between 1962 and 1975, and then turned and fell (Bratsberg and Rogeberg, 2018).

Brothers share parents, household and gene pool. A change that shows up between brothers cannot be genetic. Whatever moved those scores, up and then down, was environmental, and it operated on children growing up in the same home a few years apart. The full rise and reversal is one of the stranger stories in the field.

So: intelligence is substantially heritable, and population-level scores moved by more than any intervention has ever produced, for environmental reasons. Both are true. They are not in tension once you remember that heritability describes variation within a population at a time, and says nothing about what happens when the whole population’s circumstances change.

What moves it

Education, reliably. Each additional year is worth roughly one to five IQ points, found consistently across three research designs including natural experiments where the law rather than the family decided who stayed in school, and the gain persists (Ritchie and Tucker-Drob, 2018).

That is the cleanest refutation of the fixed reading. A highly heritable trait responding durably to an intervention is not a paradox. It is ordinary. What else is on the short list of things that work is worth knowing, and it is shorter than the internet suggests.

As a mother, where this actually lands

I come from a family that was quietly fatalistic about this. My father left school at fifteen and talked about it as though a verdict had been delivered rather than a circumstance arranged, and some of that got passed down.

What I find genuinely useful about the Wilson effect is that it reframes the parenting question. If shared family environment fades towards nothing by adulthood, then the specific enrichment decisions I agonised over, the apps and the educational toys and which reading scheme, were never where it mattered. What persists is the stuff that shapes what she chooses once she is choosing for herself: whether difficulty is interesting or threatening, whether she expects to understand things.

That is a less controllable job than buying the right product and a more interesting one. It also means my father’s fifteen was a circumstance, which is what I would have liked to tell him.

What to take from it

Do not read a heritability figure as a ceiling on your child. It is not about your child.

Do not read a score as a genetic readout. Scores move considerably through childhood, and the youngest scores predict least.

And do not conclude that effort is pointless because something is heritable. The best-evidenced intervention in the whole field is simply staying in education, and it works on a trait that is substantially heritable.

For a current reading, the free IQ test for kids is age-normed, and the adult test covers anyone over sixteen. For what the result does and does not predict, the relationship with school achievement is stronger than most people expect and still leaves a great deal open.

References

  1. Plomin, R., & Deary, I. J. (2015). Genetics and intelligence differences: Five special findings. Molecular Psychiatry, 20(1), 98-108. doi:10.1038/mp.2014.105
  2. Bratsberg, B., & Rogeberg, O. (2018). Flynn effect and its reversal are both environmentally caused. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 115(26), 6674-6678. doi:10.1073/pnas.1718793115
  3. Ritchie, S. J., & Tucker-Drob, E. M. (2018). How much does education improve intelligence? A meta-analysis. Psychological Science, 29(8), 1358-1369. doi:10.1177/0956797618774253